Florida man gets life in prison for murdering British woman he met on fetish site

Miami, Florida - A Florida man was convicted by a jury on Friday for the 2025 murder of a British woman he met on a fetish website.

 A Miami Beach Police van leaves the Miami Beach Police station in Miami Beach, Florida. A Florida man was sentenced to two life terms on November 20, 2026, for kidnapping and murdering a British woman he met online.
A Miami Beach Police van leaves the Miami Beach Police station in Miami Beach, Florida. A Florida man was sentenced to two life terms on November 20, 2026, for kidnapping and murdering a British woman he met online.  © JOE RAEDLE / GETTY IMAGES NORTH AMERICA / Getty Images via AFP

Dwain Hall (54) was found guilty of kidnapping and murdering Sonia Exelby (32) and was sentenced to two consecutive life terms, Florida prosecutors said in a statement.

"This was an extraordinary and deeply disturbing case involving circumstances that are difficult to comprehend," said Bill Gladson, state attorney for the Fifth Judicial Circuit.

According to prosecutors, Hall and the 32-year-old Exelby had communicated for about two years using a fetish website called Motherless.com and an encrypted application called Sessions.

Former Russell Brand super-fan gets massive tattoo tribute removed after shock rape conviction
Tattoos Former Russell Brand super-fan gets massive tattoo tribute removed after shock rape conviction

The now-defunct Motherless features "content that depicted various fetishes, including extreme BDSM, torture, and rape material," according to court documents.

During their exchanges, Exelby, who reportedly struggled with mental health issues, allegedly expressed a desire to be murdered.

She traveled to Gainesville, Florida, on October 10, 2025, and was picked up at the airport by Hall, according to prosecutors.

Hall, who went by the username "AlphaSadist" on Motherless.com, was accused of sexually abusing Exelby during the course of the next week and stabbing her to death.

Her body was found buried in a shallow grave near Hall's residence.

Hall was arrested after attempting to use Exelby's credit card.

Her body was found on October 17, 2025, in a wooded area of Marion Oaks, Florida, days after she was reported missing in the UK.

Investigators linked Hall to the murder through a receipt found at the scene for a shovel that was later found at his home. A search of his cell phone turned up explicit images, some of which were used as evidence in the trial

Cover photo: JOE RAEDLE / GETTY IMAGES NORTH AMERICA / Getty Images via AFP

More on Murder: