Lindsay Clancy trial sees new twist, holdout juror hit with controversial asylum offer: "He'd be welcomed"

Plymouth, Massachusetts - More information about the sole holdout juror in accused killer Lindsay Clancy's murder trial is coming to light, raising many questions about how he was selected to serve while facing numerous domestic violence allegations. However, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis is offering the holdout juror safety, and people aren't sure how to feel about it.

Lindsay Clancy appears in court in Massachusetts as the judge declares a mistrial on September 4, 2026. Florida Governor Ron DeSantis is looking to protect the sole holdout juror in Clancy's murder mistrial.   © REUTERS

Though the judge declared a mistrial in the case of Clancy on September 4, in which she is accused of killing her three young children in 2023, the plot continues to thicken.

Following the mistrial, Clancy's lead defense attorney, Kevin Reddington, said all but one member of the 12-person jury agreed with acquittal, finding Clancy not criminally liable at the time of the murders. Though the sole male juror has yet to be publicly named, his fellow jurors, including the foreperson, have spoken out about the holdout juror as news outlets continue to dig up his past.

Reports of domestic violence allegations have been uncovered by NBC10 Boston, and the outlet also discovered that the male juror had an active restraining order against him while he was listening to evidence in the case. Per the outlet, the unnamed juror faced a criminal charge in Brockton District Court for assaulting his then-wife.

American woman allegedly smuggled drugs on flight so she could "go to Japan for free"
World American woman allegedly smuggled drugs on flight so she could "go to Japan for free"

The juror's nephew, per court records obtained by NBC10 Boston, called 911 after he allegedly saw the man grab his wife by the throat and throw her into a dresser. They divorced after the incident, and the charge was dismissed, with the ex-wife telling the outlet last week that she was scared to testify against him out of fear of losing custody of her daughter.

As the public, legal experts, and Clancy's lawyer work to figure out how this juror was seated, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis appears to be offering him a helping hand, but not everyone is on board.

"A man objected to allowing a woman to kill her three young kids and get away with it, so NBC is trying to smear that juror, whose identity should be protected," DeSantis wrote on X Saturday night. "Another low for legacy media."

Ad

Holdout juror's asylum offer sparks mixed reviews

The governor then said if the unidentified man is "being harassed, Florida will provide asylum," adding, "I'm sure he'd be welcomed and appreciated."

Asylum is typically granted by a country to a person who has to flee their home nation because they face harm or fear of persecution. It is not typically allowed for citizens of the same country who reside in different states, per the UN Refugee Agency.

A post on X by Mario Nawfal, who hosts a show on X and has over 3 million followers, claims DeSantis' move sends an "obvious" message: "Florida wants to turn one juror into a national culture-war symbol."

Another X user appeared to support DeSantis' post, writing, "Protect that juror at all cost and sue NBC10," while a different user said, "Wait until they find out Kevin Redington (Clancy's lawyer) is a registered #conservative."