Google accused of "playing games with California's democracy" after blocking news sites

Mountain View, California - Google on Friday said it is testing removing links to California news sites for some users in the state as legislators mull making the search giant pay for connecting people to news.

Google said it was testing removing links to California news sites as it brands a state bill that would create a "link tax" unaccetable.
Google said it was testing removing links to California news sites as it brands a state bill that would create a "link tax" unaccetable.  © Collage: Unsplash/AbsolutVision & REUTERS

The tech titan is preparing for the possible passage of the California Journalism Preservation Act (CJPA) that would create a "link tax" for connecting users in the state to news articles, Google Global News Partnerships vice president Jaffer Zaidi said in a blog post.

The CJPA was passed by the California Assembly in June of last year, and is currently being considered by the state's senate.

"As we've shared when other countries have considered similar proposals, the uncapped financial exposure created by CJPA would be unworkable," Zaidi contended.

"If enacted, CJPA in its current form would create a level of business uncertainty that no company could accept."

Mike McGuire, president pro tempore of the California State Senate, responded to the move by calling it a "dangerous threat by Google that not only sets a terrible precedent here in America, but puts public safety at risk for Californian who depend on the news to keep us informed of life threatening emergencies and local public safety incidents."

The fight to get tech giants to pay for journalism

Google and Meta have both pushed back hard at legislative measures that aim to make them share revenue with news outlets.
Google and Meta have both pushed back hard at legislative measures that aim to make them share revenue with news outlets.  © REUTER

Google and Facebook-owner Meta have pushed back against anything that requires them to compensate news outlets for stories that make it onto their platforms.

Facebook briefly blocked news articles on its site in Australia in 2021 after the passage of a similar law, before the company and Google agreed to make deals to remunerate news publishers.

In France, an agreement was reached in 2022 between Google, publishers and press agencies to allow news content displayed on its platform.

And in November, after months of negotiations, Canada and Google signed an agreement under which the world's number one online advertising company would pay Canadian media companies $100 million a year in compensation for lost advertising revenues.

Supporters of such laws argue that the companies attract users with news stories and devour online advertising dollars that would otherwise go to struggling newsrooms.

Google to pause investments in news "ecosystem"

Google's trial involves removing links to news websites that might be covered by the proposed law to measure the effect on the platform, according to Zaidi.

Only two percent of Google search queries are news related as people shift to getting news from short-form video, newsletters, podcasts and social media, according to Zaidi.

Google is also halting investments in the California news "ecosystem" until it is clear what regulators have planned, Zaidi added.

"A healthy news industry in California will require support from both the California government and a broad base of private companies," Zaidi said.

The Media Guild of the West union slammed Google for "playing games with California's democracy," and urged Governor Gavin Newsom to stand up to the threats.

Cover photo: Collage: Unsplash/AbsolutVision & REUTERS

More on Tech: