Would Florida State's Playoff snub been prevented by 2024's planned expansion?

Tallahassee, Florida - If only the College Football Playoff (CFP) expanded this season.

The notable exclusion of Florida State from the College Football Playoff serves as a prime example of the need for an expansion from four teams to 12.
The notable exclusion of Florida State from the College Football Playoff serves as a prime example of the need for an expansion from four teams to 12.  © Isaiah Vazquez / GETTY IMAGES NORTH AMERICA / Getty Images via AFP

If the College Football Playoff had already expanded to 12 teams this year, as it is scheduled to do in 2024, the controversy surrounding Florida State's surprising snub might not have arisen.

Despite Florida State achieving the rare feat of an undefeated regular season and securing the ACC championship against Louisville with third-string quarterback Brock Glenn, they were placed at No. 5 in the final playoff rankings.

This decision raised eyebrows, particularly because both Texas and Alabama, with identical 12-1 records as conference champions, were ranked above the undefeated Florida State.

It marked the first instance in college football history where the selection committee overlooked an undefeated conference champion.

The controversy escalated further with Alabama's inclusion in the top four, leading college football experts to question whether financial considerations played a significant role.

Critics pointed out the billion-dollar deal between the SEC and ESPN, the exclusive broadcast partner of the CFP, suggesting that monetary interests influenced the committee's decision to include an SEC team in the playoff rankings.

Why is the College Football Playoff expansion important?

In the future 12-team expansion, conference champions are given automatic bids into the College Football Playoffs.
In the future 12-team expansion, conference champions are given automatic bids into the College Football Playoffs.  © Steph Chambers / GETTY IMAGES NORTH AMERICA / Getty Images via AFP

The expansion of the College Football Playoff from four teams to 12 may not completely prevent controversies surrounding the selection of top teams for future national championships.

Still, it is poised to eliminate issues similar to those arising this year.

In the proposed 12-team Playoff format, Florida State would have secured an automatic bid, potentially even achieving a higher ranking.

Both Texas and Alabama, as conference champions, would also have received automatic bids.

The revised structure aims to provide a more inclusive and comprehensive representation of top-performing teams, reducing the likelihood of contentious debates and ensuring a fairer playoff selection process.

Cover photo: Isaiah Vazquez / GETTY IMAGES NORTH AMERICA / Getty Images via AFP

More on College Football: