Biden's blurred red lines on Gaza under scrutiny after Rafah tent massacre

Washington DC - Joe Biden's red lines over Israel's assault on Rafah have kept shifting, but the president faces growing pressure to take a firmer stance after a deadly strike in the Gazan city.

President Biden is facing growing pressure to take a firmer stance on Israel's deadly assault on Rafah.
President Biden is facing growing pressure to take a firmer stance on Israel's deadly assault on Rafah.  © MANDEL NGAN / AFP

Despite global outrage over the attack in which 45 people were killed, the White House insisted on Tuesday that it did not believe Israel had launched the major operation that Biden has warned against.

John Kirby, the US National Security Council spokesman, said that Biden had been consistent and was not "moving the stick" on what defined an all-out military offensive by key ally Israel.

But Biden faces a difficult balancing act both domestically and internationally over Gaza, especially in a year when the 81-year-old Democrat is locked in an election battle with Donald Trump.

Robert F. Kennedy Jr. accuses CNN of breaking the law in last-ditch effort to make debate stage
Politicians Robert F. Kennedy Jr. accuses CNN of breaking the law in last-ditch effort to make debate stage

"Biden wants to appear tough on Rafah, and has really tried to be stern with [Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin] Netanyahu, but in an election year, his red lines are increasingly blurred," Colin Clarke, director of research at the Soufan Group, told AFP.

"I think he'll continue shifting those lines, ducking and weaving, largely in response to events on the ground."

White House confirms US policy on Israel hasn't changed

45 people were killed when Israel struck an area designated for displaced civilians in Rafah over the weekend.
45 people were killed when Israel struck an area designated for displaced civilians in Rafah over the weekend.  © REUTERS

Facing US campus protests over his support for Israel, Biden said earlier this month that he would not supply Israel with weapons for a major military operation in Rafah, and he halted a shipment of bombs.

Yet he has since taken no action even as Israel has stepped up air attacks and, as of Tuesday, moved tanks into central Rafah.

Instead, the White House has largely retreated to arguing about what does, and does not, constitute an invasion.

Biden set to unveil deportation protections for undocumented spouses of US citizens
Joe Biden Biden set to unveil deportation protections for undocumented spouses of US citizens

National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan said last week there was "no mathematical formula" and said that "what we're going to be looking at is whether there is a lot of death and destruction."

At the White House on Tuesday, his colleague Kirby faced intense questioning over the Israeli strike, which sparked a fire at a displaced persons camp in which dozens of people burned to death.

Kirby said the deaths were "heartbreaking" and "horrific" but again said there would be no change in policy towards Israel.

"We have not seen them smash into Rafah," he said. "We have not seen them go in with large units, large numbers of troops, in columns and formations in some sort of coordinated maneuver against multiple targets on the ground."

Pressure on Biden mounts both internationally and domestically

President Biden is facing increasing pressure at home over his continued support for Israel.
President Biden is facing increasing pressure at home over his continued support for Israel.  © KENT NISHIMURA / GETTY IMAGES NORTH AMERICA / GETTY IMAGES VIA AFP

But internationally, the pressure is growing on Biden, a self-described Zionist who has stuck by Netanyahu despite deep disagreements since the war began with the October 7 Hamas attack.

Questions are mounting over how long the US can tolerate an Israeli assault on Rafah when the International Court of Justice – the UN's top court, of which both the US and Israel are members – ordered it to stop.

Political pressure is also mounting on Biden at home.

Protests against his support for Israel have roiled university campuses across the United States, while many on the left wing of his Democratic Party also oppose his stance.

Republicans, however, have assailed Biden over what they say is his faltering support for Israel, with House Speaker Mike Johnson inviting Netanyahu to address Congress.

"It is indeed a difficult balancing act," Gordon Gray, a former US ambassador who is now a professor at George Washington University, told AFP.

"Threading the proverbial needle – as the Biden administration is apparently seeking to do – will only disappoint voters who feel strongly about the issue one way or another."

Gray, however, said he believed Biden's decades-old support for Israel meant he would unlikely change his position, saying he was a "rare politician who is acting out of genuine conviction rather than for his own electoral benefit."

Cover photo: MANDEL NGAN / AFP

More on Joe Biden: